Being a first-generation college student is often considered a disadvantage. When no one in your family has navigated the higher education system before, the lack of institutional knowledge around you makes it more difficult to know how to apply or take advantage of opportunities once you’re admitted.
But being first-gen in policy spaces also offers its advantages, alumni of the Princeton School of Public and International Affairs emphasized at the FIRST+ Forum last week. The gathering brought together Princeton SPIA first-gen and low-income students, allies, and alumni to discuss how to navigate those identities in public service.
A key theme that emerged: Your background and access to disadvantaged communities can help you advocate for those communities and be more thoughtful in shaping policy.
Dean Amaney Jamal talked in her opening remarks about being a first-gen student herself and joked about also being a “first-gen dean.”
“I want to encourage you to always ask the questions,” she said. “Always assume there are many different people in your situations who are also trying to figure out how to navigate these systems.”
Stefanie Mavronis MPA ’18, director of the Mayor’s Office of Neighborhood Safety and Engagement at the City of Baltimore, talked about having an “underdog energy” that she shared with other students who were also navigating Princeton as first-gen students.
“Sometimes our institutions assume that we are all starting with the same roadmap,” Mavronis said, advising students to take advantage of groups like FIRST+ to connect with one another and share resources.
Tony Solís Cruz MPA ’24, senior program manager at GiveDirectly, whose parents worked in factories and earned $5.50/hour when he was growing up undocumented in the Chicago area, advised students to consider their disadvantaged backgrounds as assets.
“It takes a lot of knowledge to be able to operate while poor,” he said. Rather than assume that someone who is pedigreed is more qualified for a role, he said, organizations should look for a mix of people including “people who, growing up, have had to think of finances in a completely different way, in a more sophisticated way.”
Marissa Molina MPP ’24, chief policy and communications officer at Community Economic Defense Project, said hailing from a disadvantaged community means that she often thinks of who is not represented in the room when a policy conversation is underway.
“I now get to be in rooms where I can either let those conversations continue, or I can say, ‘Hey, time out. Just because folks are not in the room does not mean they don’t have a say,’” she said. “We have an opportunity to be in the room – and a responsibility to make sure we don’t forget those folks.”
FIRST+ group photo.
Photo by Ambreen Ali.